Which is better heat pump or gas furnace? Warm Home 2019

Furnaces and heat pumps can warm your home. Yet they do in different ways. That is why you have to discover how and what is appropriate for you. And commonly, it is about heat pumps and furnaces.

Which is better heat pump or gas furnace?

As a direct answer, it would be the heat pump. When you think about the environment, electric bills, efficiency, and convenience, heat pumps are the best option. But still, some circumstances and factors affect why furnaces are a better option sometimes. Read on to know the reasons.

With regards to warming your home – you have choices. What is more, except if you are a pro seeing how to pick between a heat pump and a furnace can be overpowering. Not to stress, this is what you have to know to settle on the correct decision.

Warm Home Knowledge 1: Heat Pumps

warm home

Heat pumps utilize the air from the outside to both warmth a home during winter and make it cooler in summer. Essentially, this implies that your heat pump will go about two purposes. It serves as an air conditioner when the atmosphere gets hot. And it acts as a heater when it is cold outside. Thus, the heat pump is 2 in 1 – one flexible item. Notwithstanding its adaptability, heat pumps are likewise energy proficient. Think about it as a warmth transporter continually moving warm air starting with one spot then onto the next. It transports air to where you require or not, contingent upon the season. In the winter, it concentrates heat outside and circulates it to your home. During summertime, it removes hot air from inside your house making a cooler indoor condition.

Pros of having Heat Pumps

Energy Efficient

It spares energy on the grounds that moving heat is simpler than making it. Also, when it feels cold outside, there is a better than average measure of warmth holding back to be pumped. Under perfect conditions, heat pumps can move 300% more energy than it expends. Interestingly, a highly-efficient gas heater is around 90% efficient. Electricity powers heat pumps so you can spare considerably on fuel utilization. It’s over 100% efficient in calm atmospheres and can fill in as both a heater and cooling system.

Air Quality

Since it does not utilize combustions, they do not emit Carbon Monoxide. It is only one less wellspring of carbon monoxide spillage to stress over. Rather than the hot and dry air that the furnace produces, heat pumps distribute normally moist air. So they will not dry out your skin as much as the searing warmth of a furnace.

Installation Cost

Installation of a heat pump framework ordinarily costs lesser than that of a furnace. Heaters require a broad ventilation framework, which can build the expense in a home not officially suit for this need.

warm home

Cons of having Heat Pumps

Not as hot as Furnaces

All in all, the air from a heat pump is not as hot as what you get from a gas heater. It warms your home, yet it blows cooler. Thus, the hot air it produces is warmer.

Not perfect for frigid temperatures

If the outside temperature falls underneath freezing, a heat pump will experience difficulties producing enough warmth for your entire house. Supplemental frameworks are accessible to work in pair with your heat pump and kick in on the coldest days. Shockingly, these frameworks utilize a great deal of energy – counteracting the energy-efficient advantages if you often use it.

Warm Home Knowledge 2: Gas Furnace

warm home

A furnace, as a major aspect of a central warming and cooling framework, consumes fuel. And then, it distributes it all through the house. All heaters comprise of four principle segments like burners that convey and consume fuel. These are the heat exchangers, a blower, and a pipe that goes about as an exhaust for vaporous by-products. Contingent upon your circumstance, locale, and requirements, it runs on either gas or oil as fuel or a hybrid of both fuel types.

Pros of having Gas Furnaces


Generally, the cost of a gas heater is less expensive. Unit cost will shift contingent upon the size and features.

Comfortable heat

The warmth that gas heaters produce just feels hotter and toastier among other choices.


Gas furnaces, for the most part, have a more drawn out life expectancy than heat pumps.

Less upkeep

Gas heaters only operate every winter which is a few months out of every year. Thus, the maintenance prerequisites are not exactly those for heat pumps.


A gas heater has less mechanical parts than a warmth siphon, which means fewer things that can separate or breakdown.

Cons of having Heat Pumps

Dry Air

The heat that the furnace emits in winter will, in general, be dry. And it can dry out the general air in your home. Thus, you have to install a home humidifier for this.

Cost of energy

Modern energy-efficient furnaces are an immense improvement over the heaters of ten years back. Moving up to another furnace can bring down your vitality bills. However, in contrast with heat pumps, they utilize extensively more energy.

Warm Home Knowledge 3: Establishment Costs are Fairly Even

There are a few contrasts in establishment between heat pumps and furnaces. This is particularly valid if you somehow decide to change over your heater from one kind onto the next. Even so, if you are simply looking at the expense of installing another gas furnace or heat pump, they are entirely comparative. Higher efficiency models will cost you more in any case. And that is the main consideration in cost ranges. A few establishments are additionally more troublesome than others in light of access to the unit.

Warm Home Knowledge 4: Heat Pumps vs. Power Bills

Each single unit heat pumps you utilize every day will expand your power bill by $50 to $100 every month. Be that as it may, the heat pump will lessen your warming fuel bill appropriately. An ordinary family that utilizes 800 gallons of oil for each year, it diminishes by 300 gallons for heat pumps. On the off chance that oil costs $2.75 per gallon, the cost per million BTU would be $28.06. To get a similar measure of warmth, 1 million BTU, from a heat pump with the flow standard electric pace of 14.5 pennies per kilowatt-hour, it would cost you $14.71. As it were, warming your home with a heat pump is proportional to warming your home with oil for $1.44 per gallon, or 48% less.

Warm Home Knowledge 5:  What’s best depends on your Home

Each home and mortgage holder need varies. What your home is not the need of the other homes. The circumstances also vary. Thus, some broad proposals can enable you to choose what warming source is directly for you.

Heat Pumps

In the event that your winters normal around 30-40 degrees F, heat pumps are the ideal fit for your home. An atmosphere like the Southeast that has milder winter functions is admirably for heat pumps. What’s more, it is perfect for areas with low electric rates.


This is ideal in the event that your area has sharply cold winters and has temperatures reliably underneath solidifying. Furnaces are better in chilly climate atmospheres since they don’t rely upon the outside temperatures to change over to warm.

The Summary

To just think about heat pumps versus heater would not be useful as there are a few distinctive heater types. But in this post, we are talking about heat pumps versus gas heater as those are the dominating heater types. You can also gather little information about oil furnaces.

Heat pumps are commonly more effective than furnaces anyway, particularly in not-so chilly climate. They are particularly more proficient and cleaner than oil heaters since you need to consume oil to control the heater. At the point when oil runs out, you need to get it once more. Shockingly, heat pumps still perform more effectively than most gas heaters also. On the off chance that you are planning to purchase, you have to think of something aside from efficiency. Of course, you ought to think and choose what lasts longer. For heat pumps, there is no danger of carbon monoxide spills. They are also quieter to operate, and normally much cleaner than gas heaters. Many contend that heaters are superior to any heat pumps when the outside temperature dips under 35 degrees. Yet there is still some contradiction on that banter.

It does not require a lot of energy to run a blower and two fans. And that is fundamentally every one of the heat pumps needs to do to create heat. Notwithstanding, the heat pump’s effectiveness diminishes as temperatures drop. The specific temperature limit when a furnace turns out to be more proficient than heat pumps relies upon some factors. These factors are the house and different variables. For instance, Central Virginia is not known for long and strong winters. Thus, there are more advantages to putting resources into a heat pump than a heater. So in general, everything can be perfect for your home – heat pump or gas furnace, depending on situations.


You May Also Like